Talkin’ Up to the White Woman: Indigenous women and feminism

Non-fiction book about the invisibility and dominance of whiteness in feminism

During National Reconciliation Week this year, while sharing recommendations of books by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander authors, I came across this tweet:

I hadn’t even read this book let alone included it on my list, so I immediately bought a copy.

“Talkin’ Up to the White Woman: Indigenous women and feminism” by Aileen Moreton-Robinson is a thesis on the whiteness of Australian feminism. Across six chapters, the book explores:

  • Indigenous women’s own life writings,
  • the representation (and invisibility as the “norm”) of white women in feminist theory,
  • representations of Indigenous women in white women’s ethnographic writings,
  • representations of Indigenous women in white Australian feminism,
  • white women’s self-presentation in white feminist academia, and
  • Indigenous women’s self-presentation within white Australian feminism.

Moreton-Robinson argues that because of feminism’s inherent but insufficiently examined white perspective, Indigenous women are excluded, minimised or merely tolerated conditionally. She argues that because race is considered to be something that is “other”, white feminists are unable to acknowledge their own race and associated privilege, their own role in perpetuating racial discrimination and are therefore unwilling to relinquish some of that power. Moreton-Robinson stresses that because of this, white women are unable to recognise that for Indigenous women, sexism is inextricably linked to racism, and that until racial oppression is addressed, sexism cannot be adequately dealt with.

This is a complex and well-researched book that highlights an enormous barrier to intersectionality in feminism: a lack of self-awareness among white feminists. Moreton-Robinson combined literature reviews, oral history, writing by Indigenous women and other women of colour and interviews with white feminist academics to produce this work. This is an original and critical text and even though Moreton-Robinson wrote this book 20 years ago, the messages are just as relevant today as they were then. The University of Queensland Press has just released a 20th Anniversary Edition which came out a month or so after I bought my copy, which I understand includes additional commentary by Moreton-Robinson that reflects on the book’s reception by white feminists. I’m tempted to buy a copy of that as well!

Although the book is not very long, it is not an easy read. Moreton-Robinson uses an appropriately academic tone to explore complex and challenging concepts, and asks the audience – predominantly white feminists – to critically examine their own assumptions, privilege and complicity in continuing to centre whiteness in feminism. For readers new to feminist theory, this book is a great starting point because Moreton-Robinson provides an excellent historical overview of feminism. However, although Moreton-Robinson is a succinct writer, it is a lot of information to take in and this book unearths some uncomfortable truths about the role white women have played in facilitating racial oppression in Australia, especially in relation to the removal of children and stolen wages. I think the most challenging parts for me were considering mistakes I had made in the past, the diversity of perspectives I surround myself in and roles played by myself and my ancestors in perpetuating racial oppression.

This is an extremely important book that is just as relevant (if not more so) today as it was at publication 20 years ago. I recommend white women reading this book with an open mind, an open heart and a willingness to commit to taking on board the lessons the book has to offer to improve feminist practice starting with acknowledging whiteness and its associated privilege.


Filed under Australian Books, Book Reviews, Non Fiction

13 responses to “Talkin’ Up to the White Woman: Indigenous women and feminism

  1. This seems like a really nice book. I have always been inclined to exploring books written on this theme particularly

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Good on you for reading and reviewing this book Angharad. It made me laugh though because when I saw it pop up in my in-tray, I immediately assumed that you were reviewing the new 20th anniversary edition, about which I heard recently (on The Drum I think.) What a shame you bought a copy just before the new ed with updated comments came out. Anyhow, I enjoyed your review – of the content and the style. I feel I should read this too – and I suspect it would make me uncomfortable too!

    Liked by 1 person

    • I know, I had no idea a 20th anniversary edition was coming out and I tried to see if I could find an eBook so I could get the additional content but alas, was not to be! Very worthwhile reading, and really good to challenge my thinking, but I was so surprised I’m the first to review it on the AWW Challenge blog.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Sharon

    I read this some time ago, found it an eye-opening read. You have made me think about tracking down the new edition and giving it a re-read.🌻

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: Non-Fiction (General) Round Up: August & September 2020 | Australian Women Writers Challenge Blog

  5. Pingback: The Philosopher’s Daughters | Tinted Edges

  6. Pingback: Fannie Barrier Williams, Women in politics (#Review) | Whispering Gums

  7. Pingback: 2020: A Year in Books | Tinted Edges

  8. Pingback: So You Want to Talk About Race | Tinted Edges

  9. Pingback: Q&A for Angharad with books and writing as dream- and spellwork – Metaphors & Metaphysics

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s